First, check out Gulatis post about how people in the West are wasteful and that people should not point fingers when somebody is polluting the planet.
I find it ironic that he talks about how "India's duty is to her 800 million poor people" and while talking about the "efficient waste management system - the local rag-picker" so that he can slam a "fancy machine[s] at the supermarket" that "segregate the waste".
It's either a fancy machine or poverty. No one will ever pay a rag picker as much as anybody. If there are laws in place that means everyone should be paid a minimum amount of money, then there won't be a rag picker. Which, by the way, is what has happened in the west!
I'm not saying the developed world doesn't pollute. I think they overdo everything which leads to lots of pollution. Lots of cleanliness, lots of sanitisers, lots of plastic, lots of waste.
The amount of "standard of living" you get for every resource spent is a diminishing return. To be a little more comfortable, when you're already very comfortable, you need to spend a LOT more. This is pretty much what has happened in the western countries. Considering the population boom plus the standard of living boom, there is no way natural resources can keep up with human consumption.
But this is not what the post is about. It's about the "pointing fingers" Gulati is talking about. There are several points I need to talk about.
- Nobody (not in a literal sense) is blaming India for pollution or global warming. It IS the the USA and other developed countries. It's a fact. If people don't know that, then they are ignorant. So it's the peoples fault, not a scientific one.
- If normal people don't know that, there is a good reason why. Pollution in the west is NOT obvious. There is NO smoke. Ever. I have not seen smoke in the US at all. No dust. Nothing that looks like pollution. It's easy to think the place is very clean. It is! But pollution is a different thing. It hasn't got much to do with pollution, in the global warming sense. AND, companies nowadays have gotten a LOT cleaner. And are going to get hundreds of times cleaner in the coming decade.
- When people from abroad criticise India about pollution, it's not the actual pollution they are blaming. They are blaming the "don't care" mentality. It's true that Americans are polluting a lot more. But, they care. And now that they've learnt about it, they want to do something about it. The problem with Indians, not just with this pollution debate, is that they don't care. They don't take the responsibility. We've always been like that. That's the mentality that is so strikingly different. The common person is part of the debate.
It's good that India doesn't pollute. But think about the costs involved. How many maids do we have and how many "kelsa gaaru" do we have? On the other hand, look at the costs involved in keeping everyone at a high standard of living. I think both places are the extremes and both need to moderate their behaviours.
Edit: And what I find even worse is that most of the young people are strongly trying to emulate western culture. Infact, most of what we learn in school and college today is western knowledge. Except for "0". Don't say that they haven't given us anything.
And I wish people would stop talking about their own respective countries. Everywhere. The time we are in is beyond that. What happens in one part of the world affects everyone else. Think about Google, melting glaciers, Afghanistan, outsourcing and kickass research in CERN. We're all in it together. It sucks that age old traditions like patriotism still exists. I suppose cave men created the concept so that they stay together and not get eaten by bears. But that's not the case anymore.
6 drops:
Post a Comment